Pink Peppercorn Pots de Crème
I’ve sort of become the default cook for family gatherings. I like to cook, I generally have more time than others to cook, and it gives me an excuse to be in the kitchen. Which, for an introvert, is perfect for avoiding some of the inevitable small talk.
‘How’s the weather? How’s the job? How’s your pet iguana? Were you and Iggy selected to appear on the new show My Pet Haz Mad Skillz? etc…’ You know, the surface level conversations you have when you see someone once a year. I’ve never been the sort to eagerly regurgitate the happenings of the last year to say, my long-lost third cousin, who I know is just as bored with my “stories” and I am with theirs. This is going of on a very weird personal tangent so time to focus.
One year, my mom’s boyfriend decided he would cook Christmas dinner. Yes, this made me sort of twitchy, but did allow for some more engaging conversations because I wasn’t cooking!
Crème brulée was the featured dessert. Now, crème brulée is my mom’s absolute favorite dessert. She loves it and will rhapsodize about the various crème brulées that have been presented before her. So when her boyfriend announced that it would be the feature, I was looking forward to it. I assumed that with a crème brulée fanatic in the house, he knew what he was doing.
Well let’s just say it was not crème brulée. Not even close. It was closer to flan. Because it was flan. From a box. I typically have an aversion to most foods in the gelatin category. It’s a texture thing. Just jiggly and downright off-putting. It was a poor sad crème brulée impostor.
So when I run across recipes for flan or its closest boring cousin, panna cotta, I simply keep moving. I tend to lump the aforementioned desserts into two categories: flan and panna cotta in the jiggly category; crème brulée and pots de crème in the smooth and luscious category.
Last week when was flipping through the new issue of Bon Appetit, I saw a beautiful picture of a Pink Peppercorn Panna Cotta and my heart sank. Or it jiggled. Or whatever. But, here’s where I tried to get creative. I really wanted to play with some pink peppercorns. I decided to make a pots de crème with those sexy, hot pink orbs.

Pink peppercorns have a musky floral and yes, peppery smell. So rather than using sugar to sweeten my version of the pots de crème, I wanted to use honey, as honey is also very floral. I also wanted the peppercorns to be the star and any other base flavor seemed like it would steal the show.
Turns out the two paired well together. When served with the macerated cherries originally called for in the panna cotta recipe, it tasted great, only jiggly when I took it out of the oven. Actually the first time I took them out of the oven they were far from being done and I feared disaster. But by cooking them a litte longer and patiently waiting for the right amount of jiggle, they turned out wonderful.

Pink Peppercorn Pots de Crème
2 cups heavy cream
1 T. peppercorns crushed
6 egg yolks
1/2 c. honey
Macerated Cherries
6 oz. cherries, pitted and halved
1 T. sugar
one large pinch freshly ground black pepper
Heat oven to 300 degrees. Pour cream into small saucepan. Heat cream until steam rises. Turn off heat, add the crushed peppercorns. Cover pan and let steep for 10 to 15 minutes.
Meanwhile, whisk together egg yolks and honey in a large bowl. When the cream is ready, stir in about 1/4 of the cream into the egg yolk and honey mixture to temper. Slowly add in the rest of the cream to combine. Strain the final mixture into a pitcher. I scraped out some of the peppercorn flecks to add them back into the mixture. Or I could have used a strainer with a little larger holes.
Pour mixture into 6-6 ounce ramekins and place ramekins in a baking dish; fill dish with water to reach halfway up the side of the ramekins. Cover with foil. Bake 45-50 minutes, or until center is barely set or jiggly (e.g. flan-like). The pots de crème will set up as they cool, becoming more solid and smooth.
Remove from oven and chill for a few hours to set. Serve with macerated cherries. About 20 minutes before serving, remove the pots de crème from the refrigerator. Combine the ingredients for the cherries in a separate bowl and let the mixture sit while the pots lose a bit of their chill. Serve with some of the cherries spooned on top.






